Harvard Forest Code of Conduct

This code was developed in a collaborative, staff community process in 2021-2022. It is reviewed annually and was most recently updated in May 2023.

Harvard Forest is committed to fostering a respectful, open, and inclusive community that supports and implements our mission: to address environmental challenges through excellence in science, education, and engagement with society to help guide stewardship of the planet.

All members of the Harvard Forest community are expected to adhere to high standards of civility, integrity, and inclusion while on-site and while carrying out our work in the wider world. Federal and state laws and various university policies create a framework for our expectations, which apply not only to staff, students, faculty, and fellows, but also to visitors, contractors, and guests.

Beyond this framework, our role as a diverse community calls us each to show, expect, and hold each other accountable for growth in, compassion, patience, empathy, courage, and learning as we understand and embrace our differences. We are all responsible for holding our community to high standards of conduct. In addition to following all applicable Harvard University policies (see appendix and any other applicable policy given the situation at hand), we ask all members of the Harvard Forest community to uphold the core values of Harvard Forest, including Diversity and Inclusion, Collaboration, and Stewardship.

For definitions and more in-depth information, follow the hyperlinks.

Expected Conduct 

Harvard Forest expects members of its community to:

• Act with integrity, respect, and empathy toward others and the land;
• Be welcoming and inclusive of all people;
• Practice open and accessible communication to support each community member’s ability to contribute to Harvard Forest’s mission;
• When acting in a supervisor, mentor, or other leadership role, individuals should act with the knowledge of the power dynamics that may be inherent in these roles, and participate in relevant learning opportunities;
• Be mindful of how one’s actions impact the future, and contribute to the stewardship of the land and University property;
• Promote physical and mental health and safety for yourself and others;
• Avoid conflicts of interest and commitment; and
• Carefully manage public, private, and confidential information.

Unacceptable Behavior

While it is impossible to identify all of the ways someone may engage in unacceptable behavior, below is a non-exhaustive list of examples of unacceptable behavior for which Harvard Forest will take disciplinary action:

• Sexual harassment, sexual assault, stalking, and relationship violence;
• Discrimination based on any category protected by Federal or Massachusetts law;
• Retaliation;
• Incivility; 
• Bullying;
• Scholastic dishonesty, including unethical research, plagiarism, or falsification of data;
• Unauthorized use, including misuse, of Harvard land, facilities, equipment, or services;
• Illegal or unauthorized possession, use, or sharing of weapons, drugs, alcohol, or other illicit materials;
• Theft, property damage, or vandalism;
• Violation of any applicable Harvard University rules, policies, or established practices;
• Violation of any Local, State, or Federal laws; or
• Any other behavior Harvard Forest determines, in its sole discretion, to be inconsistent with its community expectations or mission.

Consequences for Unacceptable Behavior

Consequences for engaging in unacceptable behavior will depend on the individual’s role in the community and will be commensurate with the nature and severity of the offense, the individual’s history of unacceptable behavior and whether violations have been persistent, and the impact of the offense on any other people involved. The Director and/or Director of Administration and Facilities will be involved in determining consequences, along with others as appropriate. Consequences may include but are not limited to one or more of the following:

• Conversation/coaching and education around the unacceptable behavior and expectations for improvement;
• Restitution;
• Reassignment;
• Confiscation of goods or other property possessed, used, or shared illegally or in an unauthorized manner;
• Temporary suspension or permanent expulsion from Harvard Forest, its facilities (e.g., buildings), or its equipment (e.g., vehicles);
• Temporary suspension or permanent expulsion from all Harvard University properties;
• Performance counseling, performance improvement plan, warnings or other disciplinary notices, and termination of employment are potential consequences for Harvard Forest employees
• If external to Harvard, termination of formal affiliation with Harvard University/Harvard Forest; or
• Any other consequence Harvard deems appropriate, in its sole discretion, given the circumstances.
• In administering discipline, to the maximum extent permitted, there is no particular order or requirement, and certain offenses may lead to more significant consequences, without the need for implementing lesser consequences.

Harvard Forest is learning more about models of restorative justice during the 2023-2024 academic year in the hopes of including it as an option for addressing misconduct in the future. 

 
What to do if you’ve experienced or witnessed misconduct

If you believe you have experienced or witnessed misconduct, we are here to help connect you and the impacted person to care and resources. You can reach out to any or all of the following:

Local Harvard Forest resources 

• Meg Fuchs*, Director of Administration and Facilities at Harvard Forest (megfuchs@fas.harvard.edu; 717-413-2358; Shaler Hall first floor office) 
• Missy Holbrook*, Director of Harvard Forest (holbrook@oeb.harvard.edu) 
• Your supervisor/program leader/course instructor* 

*All of these individuals must report sexual/gender-based misconduct to the Gender Equity office 
 
You can also use the Harvard Forest anonymous reporting form (content goes to Meg Fuchs and Missy Holbrook). 
 
Additional resources, grouped by level of confidentiality 

Confidential resources (are not required to report to Gender Equity/Title IX office and will not disclose information to anyone else without your consent)

• 24-hour crisis hotline for sexual assault (confidential resource): (617) 495-9100
• Ombuds Office (confidential, neutral resource for any workplace or academic concern): https://ombudsman.harvard.edu/
• Office for Gender Equity (education, counseling, disclosures, and formal complaints for issues of gender-based discrimination, including sexual harassment/misconduct): https://oge.harvard.edu/options

Anonymous resources (report misconduct without disclosing your identity; concerns may be shared with Gender Equity/Title IX office, HR, Dept.)

• Any ethical, integrity, safety, security, and compliance concerns: https://reportinghotline.harvard.edu/
• Sexual harassment/misconduct: https://oge.harvard.edu/disclose

Mandated reporters (must report sexual or gender-based misconduct to Gender Equity/Title IX office)

• Meg Fuchs, Director of Administration and Facilities at Harvard Forest (megfuchs@fas.harvard.edu; 717-413-2358; Shaler Hall first floor office)
• Missy Holbrook, Director of Harvard Forest (holbrook@oeb.harvard.edu)
• Your supervisor (or any supervisor) at Harvard Forest
• Course instructor or program leader
• Bob Bellantuoni, Senior Human Resources Consultant (rbellantuoni@fas.harvard.edu; 617-496-1150)
• Danielle Farrelle, Program Officer for Title IX and Professional Conduct (farrell@fas.harvard.edu; (617) 495-0321)

If you report suspected or alleged misconduct, Harvard University has a policy that will protect you from retaliation. Note that all University employees are required to report sexual misconduct to the Title IX office. (Resources identified as “confidential” above are exempt from this requirement, and nothing you share with them, even if it falls under the category of Title IX, will be shared without your permission.)

Any report/concern we receive will be run through the process for that type of issue, and we'll follow it as far as it needs to go. Unless you submitted your report anonymously, you will receive an acknowledgement of your report within 2 business days. Please understand that due to confidentiality policies, if you make a report of something you've witnessed or been told, we may not be able to follow up with you directly about the outcome. If you make a report for something you've experienced yourself and disclose your name, you will be kept updated as to the status of the process.

Mission, Vision, and Values of the Harvard Forest

The Harvard Forest is Harvard University’s 4,000-acre laboratory and classroom, with year-round staff dedicated to long-term science and experiential learning. Our mission is to advance understanding of biological, physical, and human systems in the New England landscape. We share our research to help guide stewardship of the planet. Harvard Forest practices an open, inclusive, and collaborative approach to addressing local and global environmental challenges through excellence in science, education, and engagement with society. Our core values include excellence, diversity and inclusion, learning from the past to inform the future, collaboration, and stewardship.

Diversity & Inclusion Statement

Harvard Forest is committed to establishing and maintaining a diverse and inclusive community that collectively supports and implements our mission: the investigation, understanding, and communication of the ways in which physical, biological, and human systems interact to change our Earth.  All should feel that they are critical members of the Harvard Forest community—whatever their identities—while working, studying, visiting, or living here.  We will welcome, recruit, develop, and advance talented staff, students, and visitors from diverse backgrounds, and strive to ensure that all are included in our mission.

Indigenous Land Acknowledgement

We are working in community with the Nipmuc tribe to set a foundation to build a relationship that makes an authentic land acknowledgement possible.

Glossary of Terms

Bullying: persistent pattern of mistreatment from others in the workplace that causes either physical or emotional harm; yelling, threats, reputational harm, demeaning a person or their work product, etc.

Conflict of commitment: when outside activities interfere with one's responsibilities to an employer

Conflict of interest: a situation in which a person is in a position to derive personal benefit from actions or decisions made in their official capacity

Discriminiation: being treated differently or unfairly based on race, religious creed, national origin, sex, ability level, gender identity, sexual orientation, or other aspect of one's identity (see the Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination for more info)

Incivility: behavior that is rude, discourteous, and displays a lack of regard for others; public mocking/reprimands; etc.

Restitution: an act of restoring or a condition of being restored

Retaliation: For purposes of this policy, any form of intimidation, threat, coercion, discrimination, or reprisal

Stewardship: the careful and responsible management of something entrusted to one's care

Code of Conduct Appendix

Compiled Resources + Summaries

This appendix summarizes the resources that inform the Harvard Forest Code of Conduct. Links to each resource are included. The summaries are provided for ease of understanding the resources but do not replace or alter the meaning of the underlying resource.  If there is a conflict between what is shared in the below summary and the resource, the language of the resource shall govern.

Font Key:

Throughout this appendix, the following font styles are used to denote:

Hyperlink to the resource

Sections or titles included in the resource

“Direct Quotes”

Harvard Forest Strategic Plan (2020-2025):

• Summary: Developed in 2020, this plan details the mission and vision of Harvard Forest from now until 2025. We created action plans for each department at Harvard Forest, including ways they can help make HF a more diverse and inclusive place.
• Mission: “Advance understanding of biological, physical, and human systems in the New England Landscape. We share our research to help guide stewardship of the planet.”
• Values: Excellence, Diversity and Inclusion, Learning from the past to inform the future, Collaboration, Stewardship
• Action Plans:
  • Research
    • Expanding and diversifying the team of resident senior scientists will help advance education, outreach, and DEIB initiatives. In addition, increasing the diversity of research staff, collaborators, and resident fellows, strengthening ties with the university, and increasing broadening sources of funding will magnify the positive impact that Harvard Forest’s research will have in the scientific community.
  • Engagement and Outreach
    • Promoting Harvard Forest’s visibility, leadership, and cooperation with the main campus will allow us to incorporate new engagement goals and further develop many of the current education and outreach activities. The goals of this plan emphasize the importance of serving the community and inspiring environmental action among diverse public populations.
  • Facilities and Infrastructure
    • Facilities and Infrastructure comprise a very large set of managed resources: physical (land, residential and work units, vehicles and equipment), network (field wireless network included), and online (HF Data Archive), to name a few. Continued execution of the land use plan and regular maintenance, as well as improving accessibility, inclusivity, sustainability, and safety of HF Facilities, will contribute to the mission and values of Harvard Forest.

Framework and Facilitation Guide for Convening your Community

• Intro Statement: “When Departments, Areas, Centers and other units of the FAS consider ways to convene their communities in critical moments, the following framework and facilitation guide may be useful to those leading those discussions. It is important to create space to allow all community members to process difficult events, while acknowledging that they may impact community members differently. Processing can take many different forms including individually, one-on-one, in small groups, or collectively.”
• Summary: Includes some guiding principles and planning questions to consider before convening the community. There are lists on what to consider and what to avoid during planning. The Facilitation Guide provides a format for conducting conversations in a way that establishes a safe, confidential space for sharing concerns and asking questions without worry or fear.
• Values: advancing knowledge, commitment to truth, commitment to inclusion

Harvard-wide Policies:

• Staff Personnel Manual: Introduction
  • Summary: This website outlines what responsible conduct looks like for Harvard employees. The Introduction contains a list of conduct considered inappropriate by Harvard standards. They also provide a procedure for solving work-related problems and explain the performance correction process. The latter two may be helpful as examples. This was last updated in May 2008.
  • Non-Retaliation Policy:
    • Policy Statement: “The University expressly forbids anyone to take any form of retaliatory action against any member of the Harvard community who in good faith voices concerns, seeks advice, files a complaint or grievance, seeks the aid of Human Resources, testifies or participates in investigations, compliance reviews, proceedings or hearings, or opposes actual or perceived violations of Harvard University’s policy or unlawful acts.”
    • There are tables with relevant definitions, employee responsibilities, and procedures.
  • Office for Gender Equity Policies
    • Summary: This link contains the Sexual and Gender-Based Harassment Policy, Interim Title IX Sexual Harassment Policy, and Interim Other Sexual Misconduct Policy. For each policy there is also a link to FAQs.
    • Sexual and Gender-Based Harassment Policy:
      • Summary: Could be helpful as an example for formatting, as well as informing us of what needs to go into the CoC. Includes a Policy Statement, defines sexual and gender-based harassment, outlines jurisdiction, and provides resources.
    • Interim Title IX Sexual Harassment Policy:
      • Summary: Similar to above, with the addition of an Appendix providing definitions in federal law of sexual assault, domestic and dating violence, and stalking.
    • Interim Other Sexual Misconduct Policy:
      • Summary: Similar to above, except expands the definition of sexual misconduct by including anything “other” that was not mentioned in the first two policies.
    • At-a-Glance one-pager:
      • Summary: Summarizes the other policies and points out what all of them share in common. Good for a cursory overview of the above policies.
    • Harvard HR: Guidelines for Gender Inclusivity
      • Summary: Contains policies and guidelines for gender inclusivity in the workplace. Starts off explaining the purpose for the document and linking back to the Sexual & Gender-based Harassment Policy and the Employee Personnel Manual. Then, they define some key terms before going into university support (Title IX Coordinators), guidance, and resources for gender inclusivity.
    • Harvard HR: Discrimination Policy and Review
      • Intro Statement: “Discrimination on the basis of race, color, sex, gender identity, sexual orientation, religion, creed, national origin, age, ancestry, veteran status, disability unrelated to job requirements, genetic information, military service, pregnancy, or any other legally protected basis is unlawful and intolerable to the University.”
      • Default to Informal Problem-Solving Process when dealing with discrimination in the workplace. If that does not work, there is a Formal Complaint Process that is outlined in greater detail.
        • Starting the Formal Complaint Process: “... the employee should first make use of any discrimination complaint process at their School or administrative unit. In the absence of such a mechanism, the employee may submit a complaint of discrimination in writing to the local human resource officer.”
        • Formal Complaints Processes are expected to be completed within 90 days of issuing the complaint.
        • Next steps in the process:
          • Fact-finding: investigatory interviews, drafting up a preliminary report, HR officer or designee determines whether there was a violation of policy
          • Consideration of Findings and Determination: up to the dean, vice president, or designee to verify whether the preliminary report has collected enough evidence to prove a violation of policy. If a violation is found, corrective measures will be recommended in the decision. The imposition of these measures is up to the individual’s school or administrative unit.
        • Special Circumstances
          • Once a formal complaint has been filed, either of the involved parties may request Informal Problem-Solving instead, which requires agreement from both parties and administration.
          • If the resolution is unsatisfactory to either party, it may be appealed within 7 days of receiving the decision.
        • Graduate School of Arts and Sciences Codes of Conduct
          • These codes exist as a tab under the GSAS Policies. The Codes of Conduct outline:
            • Governance: Expectations of Conduct, Procedures for Disciplinary Cases, Possible Outcomes, Disciplinary Statistics, Related Contacts and Forms
            • Academic Integrity: standards and expectations surrounding coursework, exams, and research.
            • Campus Property, Facilities, and Resources: information on how to treat all of these with respect.
            • Public and Personal Safety: Fire Safety, Drug and Alcohol Policies, and information on dangerous weapons and threats
            • Personal and Professional Conduct: GSAS Policy on Hazing backed up by state law
            • Discrimination and Harassment: provides elaboration on this policy (a lot of which lines up with expectations outlined in the Harvard HR Discrimination Policy), as well as direct points of contact for graduate students when it comes to dealing with various issues under this umbrella.
          • Harvard OEDIB Statement on Campus Culture
            • *scroll down a little on the page to “Where Everyone Can Thrive”*
            • Intro Statement: “Harvard University is committed to fostering a campus culture where everyone can thrive, a key to which is ensuring that we each experience a profound sense of inclusion and belonging.”
            • Core Values:
              • Respect the rights, differences, and dignity of others
              • Demonstrate honesty and integrity in all dealings
              • Pursue excellence conscientiously in one’s work
              • Be accountable for actions and conduct in the community
              • Cultivate bonds and bridges that enable all to grow and learn from one another

State-wide Policy:

• Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination (MCAD) Know Your Rights Overview
  • MCAD enforces state anti-discrimination laws by investigating and mediating complaints in employment, housing, public accommodations, and education. MCAD also informs and educates the public on their rights and responsibilities.
  • This resource explains how to file a complaint and provides examples of the most common forms of unlawful discrimination covered under Massachusetts state law.
  • Protected groups in employment: there are criteria for groupings related to age, criminal record, disability, sex/gender, gender identity, genetics, active military or veteran status, ancestry/national origin, religion, race/color, and sexual orientation.
    • Employees in majority groups and minority groups are protected from discrimination at work.
    • An employee can be protected from discrimination if they are perceived to be a member of a group, or if they are associated with someone from another protected category.
  • Describes two different types of sexual harassment: when an employee in a position of power leverages that for sexual favors, and when a hostile work environment is defined by sexual advances and discomfort that interferes with work performance.